Hinchman Chapter 6

Most often when I read a book for an education class, I am either in complete agreement with the author or am strongly opposed. For this chapter, I found myself stepping a toe onto both sides. In chapter six, Munger and Murray discussed the importance of text complexity and deliberate practice. In their opinion, teachers must identify each student's reading levels, offer students a variety of books and reading assignments in that level, and gradually move students to higher levels as they progress through school.
My biggest problem with the reading dealt with the issue of fiction vs. nonfiction reading assignments. As a social studies teacher, I understand the importance of reading nonfiction in class. However, I believe students can gain very important skills from reading fiction, such as inferencing, hypothesizing, looking for meaning, and increasing vocabulary. I do not think students should read more non-fiction than fiction; I believe both are equally important. Historical fiction can help students gain a much greater understanding of certain topics than a textbook, and I plan on using fiction in my classroom. The chapter also focused heavily on the idea of teachers constantly challenging and pushing students to further their reading level at a very specific pace. I think teachers need to be very careful and cautious, treating each student individually. I remember as a child picking up books that were well beyond my reading abilities. However, with support from family and teachers, I was able to increase my reading levels significantly. I was willing to take the challenge. Other students might not want to move past lower-reading levels. According to the author, this is because these students feel comfortable at a specific reading level. I would like to argue these students might be feeling insecure about reading, and do not feel motivated to put themselves out there. I think teachers need to not only teach reading skills and abilities, but teach students self-motivation to want to challenge themselves.
Munger and Murray partner the ideas of text complexity with deliberate practice. They believe a student cannot achieve higher reading skills without practicing. At first when I read this, my mind went to Malcom Gladwell's book called Outliers. In this book, Gladwell states that in order to become a master of a skill, there must be 10,000 hours put in of work or practice. This chapter flipped the idea on its head for me. According to the authors, it is not 10,000 hours of practice that makes one a 'master reader.' "The notion that skills do not improve much once they become automatic is one reason teachers who use repeated reading of texts to build fluency do not involve students in reading the same passage a dozen times... What we can take from discussions based on learning theory is that challenging tasks are required to improve skills and that not all of these challenges will be enjoyable" (p. 111-112). It is not just the 10,000 hours, but the willingness to step out of one's comfort zone and push oneself to try new experiences that might not be fun for students. Therefore, I believe motivation is a key factor in helping students increase their reading levels.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hinchman Chapter 19, Beers Chapter 17

Hinchman Chapter 12

Hinchman Chapter 3 and Beers Chapter 16